Yahoo spam protection needs tweaking
January 31, 2005
Yahoo likes to talk a lot about its oh-so-cool tools to fight spam, but just how effective are they? I have a yahoo ID that I use only for instant messenger chatting. Of course it has its own mail account too which I stopped using a few years ago. Of late, however, Yahoo has started letting a lot of obvious spam through its "protection".
Don't believe me? Here's a screenshot of my in-box the last time I checked mail on the yahoo account.

Apart from the first one which was legit mail (I've blurred it), the other messages are clearly spam. They aren't even the more deceptive ones that have benign subject lines like "hello", "how are you doing", or "I forgot to tell you".
Yet Yahoo fails to classify them as spam. They need to tweak their algorithm a bit, I suppose.
(And before somebody asks, yes, the "SpamGuard" option is enabled on my account. I checked twice.)
TrackBack (0)
well, as you use the account only for IM use, you might have given out the email id to a lot of sites for registration purposes. If you guard your id from such sites, you hardly ever receive spam. Many people now have an id just for this purpose (which incidently, is the id they use just for IM).
It is true, however that a decent email filter should weed out all such msgs.
No, I never give out that address. I just use Mailinator instead.
Posted by MadMan at January 31, 2005 3:19 AMI get the same garbage in my yahoo account. I stated suspecting that most of these spam filtering efforts are not being maintained like they used to. I'm using Earthlink's spamBlocker, which requires senders to authenticate if I don't pre-authorize them. It's a pain sometimes, but works.
Posted by Ron Zeno at January 31, 2005 12:30 PM<aol>Me too</aol>. On the other hand, my Hotmail address gets something like 3 pieces of junk a day, all caught by the junk mail filter, despite being used for domain registrations.
And don't even get me started on the bloat in Yahoo Messenger... :-(
Posted by Prasenjeet Dutta at January 31, 2005 2:13 PMI'm using the Yahoo for some years.. it's really gud in filtering SPAM.. once in a week i get some spam into my INBOX.. rest all goes to Bulk Mail.. Did u enable Bulk Mail option?
Posted by Sathish at January 31, 2005 2:14 PMSatish, I wrote the last line of my blog entry just for you. :)
Prasenjeet, Yahoo messenger is so bloated that it just starts eating more and more system resources. Check the "GDI Objects" in Task Manager. It's a hog and a half.
Posted by MadMan at January 31, 2005 4:25 PMYour mail account is supposed to be disabled if you donot use it for a while.
Its their way of keeping it alive :)
I agree with Madman. Yahoo definately needs to improve this. And so is the case with Rediff. They even have a system of reporting the email to so called administration as spam.
I created an account and sent out contents copied from an email classified as spamm many times. To my surprise, it still delivers in Inbox.
I think its high time now email systems also start with something like Captcha
I get 50 spams per day on Yahoo, but only 1-2 end up in my inbox.
Strangely enough, this morning, "Laptop Giveaway" and "soulmate" emails landed in my junk mailbox on yahoo, and not in the inbox like your case.
Posted by Niket at January 31, 2005 9:15 PMI have abandoned my yahoo mail account long ago. It is practically unusable for quite a while due to the amount of spam I receive there. Besides, having my own dedicated server means that I dont use free mail accounts much nowadays. I however use Gmail frequently to check mail problems on my server.
My guess of the inefficiency of Yahoo is the fact that it expects its users to train their own personal spam filter. So to have effective spam control, you need to log in regularly and train their filter by reporting spam. Those who use Yahoo regularly and report spam faithfully, have told me that Yahoo anti-spam works for them.
Posted by Sandip Bhattacharya at February 1, 2005 4:19 PMHmm.. me dumbo!!
anyways It works well for me :-)
hi mm,
me a firstie visitor to ur page...needless to say blown over by the template...
ya yahoo mail spam filter is slowly loosing sheen...but somehow i find myself not deleting them....call it the perils of having 250mb storage space...
hiyaa me too from bangalroe
sathya
Well then I wonder why I do not get any spam in my Yahoo inbox! Nearly all of it gets routed to the Bulk Mail folder. Sometimes a solitary mail does escape the filters and land in the inbox, but thats perhaps one in 2-3 days. Here I can see that you're getting about 6-7 spam mails daily in the inbox!
You think maybe it has something to do with the filters not being upgraded promptly on some mirrors?
Posted by Sameer at February 23, 2005 10:00 PMAgain late but, my $0.2! OK, quite jobless today...
I NEVER get junk in yahoo! Some spam yes. Hotmail is another story tho' :( But then my hotmail id is the one e.one has, so guess its not just me, its my *friends* who help me attract that fluff.
Every morning I have to perform the daily ritual of sweeping through my accounts- ugh! it sounds as horrible as it is. Wish I were smarter to able to get it all in one place, but then as you say, it may crash and I be cold turkeying all day! Fell for your silly trap- was so keen to write and finally click on that link below to increase the size of the box, hahaha!
in the name of god
hi please visit
I have to opposite problem with Yahoo's Spam Protection. It keeps putting "friends" into the Spam folder, even though I repeatedly mark the Emails as "not spam". I'll get that one message, but then the next week it'll block again. It makes me have to examine my Spam (bulk) folder on a daily basis. I might as well turn it off.
S
Posted by Raptor at May 3, 2007 7:05 PMPost a comment
Note:
- Disagreement is expected. Abuse is not.
- If you use SMS-speak (u, l8r, newaz, etc.), I will delete your comment. Use proper English!
- Your IP address is logged.
- HTML is allowed in comments (but certain tags are filtered out.)
- Your email address or web site URL will be visible for others to see.


Reader comments